The UK's Finest Video Channel for Switched On Men

Login | Register

games: Buttons: A Potted History

If there’s one thing that idiots hate about video games, it’s all the buttons. “Not liking all the buttons” is the dividing factor between people like you, and me - excellent people, who deserve medals - and the enemy. The enemy are winning. Games like Nintendo’s Let’s Tap and Microsoft’s Project Natal have virtually eliminated buttons from the gaming world. How did it get to this? Where did our buttons go? Only science can tell us.

PART ONE: THE RISE OF THE BUTTON

When arcade games first started trickling into the arcades, buttons were king. In 1978, SPACE INVADERS laid down the basics. Left, right, and fire. It was fewer buttons than a tramp’s shirt, but it was a start. As humans became aware of the second dimension, they began to demand movement in the crazy world of up and down. Asteroids did this with one button - thrust - and you moved around like five buttons. Clockwise, Anticlockwise, Thrust, Fire, and the excellent Hyperspace panic button. It
Meanwhile, Pac-Man (spits) was the first game to become popular with mothers and simpletons, thanks to a hypnotic wakka wakka sound, and a complete lack of buttons. Seriously - you could play the game with your hands tied behind your back, just using your mouth, if you didn’t mind looking a bit… well, a bit sex-starved.

PART TWO: THE JOYSTICK ATTACKS

Joysticks were coming in, and taking the jobs of honest buttons - take 1981’s Vanguard, from SNK. It had four buttons devoted to firing lasers in four crazy directions. The very next year, Robotron 2084 replaced all four buttons with a joystick, and let you fire in 8 directions. Firing with a joystick? This left millions of buttons unemployed. Piles of buttons mounted up outside factories. Children would come and press the buttons, hoping something would jump or fire a laser. And the sad-eyed janitor had to explain that they were going to be taken away and burned.

PART THREE: BUTTONS AND JOYSTICKS

It was a sad time, when anyone could enjoy video games. Aggressive games like Sinistar would try to keep the casuals out, by shouting “RUN, COWARDS” as you walked past. Meanwhile, William’s Defender was trying to weed out the softcore by giving them heart attacks from the stress and flashing lights. But it was consoles, and the third dimension, that would bring buttons back. Resident Evil used the same control system as Asteroids, so that was useless - but it was the use of the two joysticks to control movement, strafe and camera that meant everything else had to be done with beautiful buttons. Fire, reload, crouch, alt-fire, jump, pause, look at a map, dance, squeal, do this - [chatters teeth, like eating invisible head-level fruit] - all needed a button.

PART FOUR: MORE BUTTONS PLEASE

In 2001, the Xbox introduced the black and white buttons, on controllers so large that you could sit on them, and ride around the house using the vibrate function. They even started hiding buttons underneath the joysticks, which was the sweetest victory after the winter of Robotron 2084. But Capcom weren’t happy with that, though - and released Steel Batallion, a game which required you to sit at a desk, at a huge controller with around 40 buttons. If you had one, then you’re either a hero, or a dick. No-one can decide.

PART FIVE: THE NEWEST THREAT

So, from 1978 to 2002, we’ve gone from 3 buttons, to 40. In 2004, World of Warcraft got PC gamers to use their entire keyboard, so by rights, in 2009, we should have games that require (thinks) 260 buttons. What went wrong? Your mum went wrong. Your mum, who liked Pac-Man, wrote a letter to Nintendo, and she said “Dear Nintendo, I remember Pac-Man didn’t have any buttons, and I liked Pac-Man, also I’m a bit worried I’m fat, and I don’t know what my heart rate is, please help, Love from YOUR MUM PS Did I mention that I’ve got loads more money than my children, who are currently riding around the house on Xbox controllers”.

The button will rise again. As long as we want to accomplish big things with zero effort, the button will be waiting for us. As long as humans get embarrassed when people walk past their window to see them on their Balance Boards, the button will be there.

Stay strong, brothers. Our time will come again.

comments

Chris
July 8th, 2009 - 12:30pm

Very entertaining to read.

Maybe a quick mention of the complete disappearance of button on the iPhone…

RattyocasteR
July 8th, 2009 - 4:10pm

Long live buttons! It’s the reason that some console ports are easier to play on the PC, everything is just, there. Of course the mouse helps in a big way, God forbid that all those rodents become unemployed by the evil (and usually inaccurate) ir pointer and sensor bar!
I honestly don’t know how people cope playing C&C on a pad…I’m rubbish at C&C yet still attempt to make use of shortcut keys, control groups as well as quick queue shortcuts in the built queue, You can’t fit all that on a pad in any sane way. I’m aware that it will be many years before keyboards and mice die off (it’d better be!) but there’s a reason that most of the popular games on the wii are casual games, because casual people play them, and for the most part won’t watch this, or read what I’m saying.
This makes me wonder…why bother reviewing Wii games? even if it’s catastrophically bad people will still buy them because they can feel good about the £240 they blew on a bowling game and a piece of plastic to wobble around on whilst any real gamers will be giving money to Sony or Microsoft. I’m not trying to start a console war here (I’ve had all 3 platforms and had time to decide) but in general, gamers buy the 360 or a PS3 and get a Wii just for a laugh and often the Wii gets used by their other half more because it’s easier to get into and more casual, as for console sales, the Wii is the most accessible platform due to it’s relatively unique interface.
Buttons are hardcore, end of!

sadface
July 8th, 2009 - 7:37pm

I wish they would bring the other girl back because this site is rubbish now :(

Wayne Naylor
July 9th, 2009 - 12:25am

I totally agree. I respect the wii for bringing a lot attention to the market but at the same time their shitty lifestyle games annoy the hell out of me. I mean the 360 and ps3 have awesome games like uncharted, halo 3, mgs4 and bioshock yet wii fit outsells them all which is just a damn shame. Hopefully the button will rise again and end the plethora of dog training and brain age games flooding the charts and stores. Great feature and nice job. Can’t wait for the next feature Zoe. Peace.

Peter Stothard
July 9th, 2009 - 1:50am

I have been a loyal follower of Channelflip podcasts and videos but I have to say Channelflip games videos and podcasts have gotten much worse since Zoe Cornwell took over. I think many new games coming out are not getting test properly and when a new video does come out it is about rubbish. For example the history of buttons, I dont see any entertainment in that. I think you’s need to get back to testing and review new games that people will buy instead of just making videos like this. Bring back Katharine

July 9th, 2009 - 8:36am

Sorry guys but Katharine is not coming back so for now you’re going to have to put up with my rants about buttons and what not (which some viewers find entertaining- thanks Wayne).
I will be looking at new games but as you may know we’ve been a little behind recently.
Stay tuned, there’s some great stuff coming up…

July 9th, 2009 - 9:18am

Good for you Zoe.

Yes, Katharine was good but Zoe’s doing great in my humble opinion. Everyone needs to appreciate that presenters have different deliveries and styles so give the girl a break.

What I would suggest is that the ChannelFlip production crew make your sets a little more…well, gamer-ish (if such a word exists). The laid back chair approach just doesn’t fit well for this section. Maybe they can work on that with you and give the show a bit more umph.

You’ve got a sexy voice by the way.

RattyocasteR
July 9th, 2009 - 11:25am

I have to admit a more games themed studio would be nice, much like the old one…unless of course that was just Katharine’s flat, or did she just get that when she cleared out her desk (Pah, and all I managed to score from my last job was a satnav!). In any case, has anyone noticed there hasn’t been that many…good, games out lately? there hasn’t been anything to review, Sims3 will take about 3 years to get to anywhere near reviewable (it’s huge, it’s not that great in my opinion and it’s an EA game so it has more bugs than a festival toilet - like the rest).
Just wait until the end of the year children, Max Payne 3 (it’s doing well to stay under the radar but even Rockstar Games say it should be out for Christmas), Forza 3, GT5 (If it’s done…), probably another Tomb Raider, Tekken 6…
Start moaning about not reviewing games when there’s games around to review, it’s summer(ish) go outside, take a break from games so you can come back refreshed in the autumn.
In my opinion, it’s a different show now that Zoe has taken over, and she’s doing a great job, more amusing. If you don’t like Channel Flip games…feel free to find an alternative.
Good Job Zoe

Dan
July 9th, 2009 - 9:49pm

I’m not sure about the exact merits of a history of buttons… but your reviews are great Zoe :)
(excluding your non appreciation of the awesomeness of Vin Diesel ;).

July 9th, 2009 - 11:59pm

Aw man, I’m feeling the love! Thanks guys!
Also, thanks for the feedback, I really appreciate it- and yes, I have learnt to appreciate Vin Deisel now. I even like his haircut. Does he even have hair?!

nice
July 10th, 2009 - 11:37am

nice. taking the piss out of people who enjoy games. smart move. (yes, that IS sarcasm)

July 10th, 2009 - 11:47am

If that’s the case Nice I’d be taking the piss out of myself since I enjoy games too.
It was just a joke, no sarcasm.

July 10th, 2009 - 11:49am

Right- anyone got any good games in mind that they’d like to see reviewed on here soon? We need to catch up! :)
You can always find my on facebook (the link in my name) and email me your suggestions x

July 11th, 2009 - 9:29am

One of the great things about in-game money and virtual economies is that they never went through this whole economic meltdown. So take that to all of those people who think the real world is better then computer games!
Barbara

July 11th, 2009 - 9:30am

Well… I visit your website first time and found this site very useful and interesting! Well… you guys doing nice work and I just want to say that keep rocking and keep it up!!!
Barbara
Buy WoW Gold

July 11th, 2009 - 9:31am

This is a terrific site! It has been very informative and useful to me. I have found several useful products. Just wanted to let you know how much I enjoy your website. I find it really useful. Thank you so much for all the info. I received from your sites!
Barbara
Buy WoW Gold

Enoch
July 11th, 2009 - 5:00pm

A bot got through the captcha ;)

Right, this was pretty cool :) For once I don’t know what the complainer’s problems are, this was just fun on more than one level.

Answering your question, Zoe, I’d like to see a review of Overlord 2.

July 11th, 2009 - 8:14pm

The review was Ok Zoe, but you didn’t mention much about the SEGA and the SNES, and those I think, were the first games that lead to modern gamers after ATARI.

Cheers!!

RattyocasteR
July 11th, 2009 - 8:35pm

Actually jpdeleon has a point. The Nes and the Master System (I’ve never had one, I’ve read about them in books though…I had a Mega Drive, or a Genesis depending where the people reading this are from) popularised the Joypad as an input device. Then a few years came and went and the Playstation pad was ok, the Dual Analogue came out and people thought it was interesting and then the Dualshock came out. Realistically speaking, that design have been around for a decade now, even the XBOX 360 controller is very very similar, They’ve changed the overall shape and swapped the d-pad and the left analogue stick and that is it from an end user perspective.

paul
July 12th, 2009 - 10:02pm

Hi, are you making this show any more? seems not, shame

Wayne Naylor
July 13th, 2009 - 10:57am

I think you should review one of the three big sandbox titles that have come out red faction guerilla, prototype or infamous. You could review ghostbusters or even ufc. Anyone of them could make a great segment. Lol at the your mum bit in this video.

Match
July 20th, 2009 - 4:36pm

hmm… buttons… mildly entertaining “history of buttons”, I guess, although I’d say it was a bit odd in the chronologic department. Remember the Falcon flight sims and others on Amiga, for example? Some of those had the keys of the keyboard mapped twice or more. Text adventures actually required typing text, so they pretty much used every key on the keyboard, too.
I guess that’s why I didn’t find this as entertaining as it could have been: It tried to hard to get the number of buttons to increase over time, which just isn’t the case.
Still, good idea.

As for good games to review: Fight Night Round 4 is a fun game. I don’t enjoy real-life boxing at all, but this game somehow manages to make it fun. Sims 3 would be another choice, Street Fighter IV, Trine and probably tons more I forogt. Oh, Daggerfall went freeware recently, so that would be a neat review for all the people who missed it back in the days. I’m still waiting for a real summer drought, I have more stuff to play than I can handle.

Richard
July 21st, 2009 - 1:26pm

Answering rattyocaster’s post that there have been no good games to review is just rubbish. The entire premise and purpose of a games review is that many new releases a covered to provide the viewer/reader with a detailed opinion of the content and substance of the game. From this you should then be able to make your own opinion of whether this is a game that you wish to invest your time and money into or not. For example Zoe did not like Vin Diesel however she still reviewed the title, Dan clearly liked Vin Diesel and so bought the game with a fond appreciation for it, regardless of how bad it may or may not have been.

In the previous 2 months we have already witnessed the release of Tiger Woods 2010, Prototype, inFamous, Redfaction, Final Fantasy 7, Monster Hunter, Fight Night 4 and many more, all of which would have been worth a review, and previously would have been reviewed.

The reality is that Katherine has left and Zoe is now here and gathering mixed responses. The excuse of there being major changes at the company and sickness is poor, and should not have affected the productions as previously demonstrated when Channel Flip resorted to filming outside.

What you are all struggling to come to terms with is that Zoe, like Katharine before her is not actually a gamer. Hard as may be to believe but Katharine was not a gamer until she worked for channel flip as is true for Zoe. Both were recruited for their appeal to the market and chosen for their presenting skills rather than a passion for the industry or understanding there of. Impossible i hear you say…. no. Katharine was clearly a very intelligent lady who through her studies had a very firm grasp on the english language, and was able to quickly pickup and research the industry to effectively carry out her reviews which we all grew to love, the reality is she could have presented a knitting channel and we would have probably all ended up with ridiculously coloured scarves.

Unfortunately Zoe is not Katharine, which is not her fault, but, results in the reviews and style that we have all seen, and a request of what shall i review next as i can’t decide.

I would much rather Zoe that you selected exactly what you want to review, and to be honest your vlog of buttons is actually one of my favorite videos that you have produced, you are at your best when you can be yourself.

Jason
July 21st, 2009 - 5:43pm

Richard said - “Hard as may be to believe but Katharine was not a gamer until she worked for channel flip”

Where on earth did you get that piece of nonsense from?

Katharine was (and still is) a avid gamer who was at school with Will Harris who is co-founder of Channelflip. She wasn’t recruited for her appeal to the market and presenting skills but because she’s an intelligent gamer who Will knows.

July 21st, 2009 - 7:15pm

Hey guys, believe it or not I do have an interest in games.
I’ve been playing since I was knee high (It all started with the Sega and Sonic the Hedgehog)
My dad and brother also have an interest in games so I couldn’t really ignore them and so I started kicking their arses at games such a SSX Tricky, Tekken and Gran Turismo. My interest for games continued from there and to this day I still play against both of them… Needless to say, they have very sore bottoms.

I also know that Katharine was a gamer too and just because we’re ladies (Yes, I’m a laaaaaady) doesn’t mean to say that we suck at games. I also like mud, motorcross and other ‘boyish’ things- blame it on living with two males. (I also like flowers, chocolates and shopping)

I really appreciate your comment Richard, I’m glad you approve of me just being myself but the reason I asked for you all to give me some ideas is due to us being a little behind here in the land of Channelflip recently. I’d just like to know what you’d all like to see since you haven’t really seen anything in a while.

Thank you to everyone for your feedback and support, I’ll definitely be considering your ideas.

I’m going to take a breath now…

Fission Mailed
July 24th, 2009 - 2:42pm

Any news on any more content… seems very slow here for the last few months… I do keep popping back here every week to check but have stopped my podcast subscription. I guess a lot of subscribers may have given up by now.

Hope to see you soon!

Tremaine
July 26th, 2009 - 11:47pm

I just wanted to post my support for Zoe, like most I was sad to see Katherine leave. However, I think Zoe has been doing a good job and would love to see more of her thoughts on new games! More reviews please!

Zoe, you’ve asked us what we would like. I’d quite like to know the games you go back to. For me it’s always Civilization (used to be 2, but now is 4). What’s the game that occupies you most at this moment? You say your Dad and brother are gamers, how about reviewing what they are currently playing?

I’m also really interested in anything in the RPG genre. I’ve been playing the latest Star Ocean and replaying Fable 2. Or MMO’s, I’m quite fond of both LotRO and FFXI (new content is added regularly for pretty much all MMOs).

How about facebook games (damn you Mafia wars for taking up my time!)

I enjoy your reviews, so please produce more content for me to consume!

Fission Mailed
July 29th, 2009 - 12:04pm

So after being told that things are finally getting back on track there has been 3 full weeks since the last podcast…

I used to enjoy these little podcasts but think it’s time I stop checking for new content.

Was good while it lasted…

Good bye and good luck!

Match
August 8th, 2009 - 11:01am

So… a month ago we were supposed to “stay tuned”. Since then there has been no new content here. Too bad, I’m out.

August 8th, 2009 - 9:00pm

Nice Video - Ignore the youtube generation - more more more more more …….
They need a different tune!
I’d like more on Buttons please there cool! - Not sure I like all the flailing about with arms but thats coz i have SMA in a wheelchair and well err I like buttons especially Big red buttons that say do not press Muhahahahah err sorry about that.
Yey Vin Diesel - Oh I actually really like the Dark Athena Game it was fantastic and cured me of any ill feelings I had after watching BABLON AD lol…

and common Channel Flip give Zoe more resources the game reviews have always been the signature pieces next to the tech reviews on this site..!

Ron
August 10th, 2009 - 8:10pm

Hey, I love a well placed button as much as the next guy…still looking forward to playing with project Natal though.

I don’t know if you review iphone apps, but I’m going to suggest a review of the “All 51 Games Free” app (DS Effects)…that should help since Zoe is a little behind in her reviews and it would combine a lot of games in one fell swoop!

Any idea when the next review might be…?

August 13th, 2009 - 6:03pm

:(
Bye for now guys.

tom s williams
August 13th, 2009 - 11:06pm

Dear Zoe , I miss katharine and i was wondering if anyone still keeps in touch with her at channelflip? I think that you are doing a fine job and keep it up ok? KATHARINE WHERE ARE YOU?????

Enoch
August 20th, 2009 - 9:06pm

Zoe, but, but Zoe? Ah girl, I wish you would have left with an overwhelmingly positive reaction to your shows. I liked them… Bye for now, and all the best for your future!

ew1
August 22nd, 2009 - 10:25am

Wait a minute, have I missed something?

Zoe is leaving?

Why?

I know everyone was getting annoyed that she has replaced Katherine, but she was still doing a great job!

Everyone who was complaining should be ashamed of themselves.

Zoe I think you were funny and informative.

If you read this, believe me, more people want you to stay than want you to go.

too much think! Need shoot!
August 22nd, 2009 - 11:19pm

get katherines videos back!

Answers on postcard
August 23rd, 2009 - 3:18pm

Perhaps if someone from Channel Flip could answer us we’d know a bit more?????

Jack_Vykios
August 23rd, 2009 - 6:11pm

From what I can tell, there’s one problem with this site. Zoe ain’t it; it’s the complete and utter lack of updates. I mean, seriously, wtf?

Gareth
August 24th, 2009 - 12:23am

Zoe has produced some great content and she should feel proud of that. The only problem is that there isn’t enough of it. I hope to see more materializing on my ipod in the near future.

August 24th, 2009 - 8:16am

Hey Fellow Channelflippians, Zoe was great she was entertaining to say the least, but ChannelFlip has decided to go in a different Direction, as soon as I know something I will update you guys.

All I can say for now is please be patient we are still in the creative process to bring you Gents and Ladies some awesome new content.

Answers on postcard
August 24th, 2009 - 9:19am

Thanks Arnold but that answer is getting kinda boring. You need to start delivering on these promises. I reckon Zoe has been let down by a lack of support by the team hence the new “direction”.

I’m done. Bye.

August 24th, 2009 - 5:29pm

Thanks so much for your support guys, it’s a real shame about this show coming to a halt but don’t worry, I’m sure whatever Channelflip has got lined up will be just great.
Keep in touch y’all.
XxXxXx

tom s williams
August 24th, 2009 - 9:42pm

hello wil harris, I was told along time ago that you and katharine were friends.have you talked to her lately? and if so could you talk to her about coming back to the show or at least sit in for a while until you can find someone else? I would love to here from her as would everyone else. also could you run some old channelflip shows with katharine in them? thank in advance tom s williams

Daniel Flugt
September 2nd, 2009 - 3:17pm

What a shame, I really liked Zoe…

Dan
September 12th, 2009 - 4:44pm

Me too. Sad to see Zoe go. These game reviews are one of the few parts of ChannelFlip I came to see.

Fission Mailed
September 22nd, 2009 - 12:33pm

Is new content really coming? I mean really… It’s a month since you said it would?

Zoe was doing a good job.

I don’t know the ins an outs that went on behind the scenes. If the games thread is not coming back why not just say so…leave the existing reviews in place

Arnold Pistorius

August 24th, 2009 - 8:16am

Hey Fellow Channelflippians, Zoe was great she was entertaining to say the least, but ChannelFlip has decided to go in a different Direction, as soon as I know something I will update you guys.

All I can say for now is please be patient we are still in the creative process to bring you Gents and Ladies some awesome new content.

October 8th, 2009 - 8:33pm

Gutted - no more CF games videos? Zoe, you’re a great presenter! Let us know if you’re presenting anything else!!

October 17th, 2009 - 3:47pm

Gah, I hate too many buttons.
I love video games, but having lots of buttons is akin to early graphic adventure games where you have to hit different buttons to do “open” then you do “use”.
Context-sensitivity is sensible, and in 99% of games these days only a few buttons should be necessary.

Difficulty should come from not the learning, but the playing. From the nature of the game, the choices you make and reactions you need…not the interface. The interface should be as “transparent” as possible.

Its not about easy/hard, its about quality of interface design. How well does an action map to a button?

This is where the Wii and Natal have their strength…they give developers more options and potential allow better solutions where the “mapping” of movement to a button dosnt make sense.
(or an analogue stick, for that mater).

Sports are the easiest examples. The wiimote corresponding to a tennis racket or baseball bat makes a lot more sense *and* is potential more accurate and subtle then any combination of button presses you attempt to make.
Likewise the sensor bar is a faster, and vastely more accurate way to aim then a stick is. (but less so then a mouse).

On the other hand, if you use a wiimotes motion sensors to trigger a gun firing or a character jumping…then your mental. A button makes far more sense for that.

Or character movement…a analogue stick is *perfect* for that. I dought we will ever invent something better.

Different tools for different jobs.
This is why at the moment Natal has a minor flaw, incidently; Unlike the wiimote, you cant easily use buttons and movements at the same time.

In short, it needs a wireless nunchuck.
Playing Halo with Metroid Corruption style controlls would be utterly fantastic. Make it happen Microsoft!.

October 22nd, 2009 - 12:47pm

Still no new content from ChannelFlip. How come? Will there be a new presenter. What’s going on?

October 22nd, 2009 - 3:35pm

Hey all,

Thanks for posting and thanks for missing us!

As you will no doubt have gathered, we’ve been doing a lot more work with the Rob Llewellyn’s, Rufus Hound’s and David Mitchell’s of the world recently and this is going to be our focus on ChannelFlip going forward.

CFGames will return in the new year with an exciting revamp that will keep you entertained and someone very exciting bringing it to you…

Sorry to stay mum on the topic but we can’t announce it yet… hopefully you guys can stay entertained in the coming weeks by Rob and Rufus - not to mention a very exciting couple more very funny people you will recognise :)

Thanks for all your continued support! -Wil

October 23rd, 2009 - 12:37pm

Before you go changing the CFGames, can you please make sure you keep my shows and put them on a disc for me please?

Thanks,

Hope everyone is well!

Zoe

paul
October 24th, 2009 - 2:31am

Please let this be katherine returning!

Enoch
October 25th, 2009 - 9:15pm

Good to hear that things on here aren’t dying! Looking forward to the new stuff.

Zoe, I sure hope you can get to keep your work in some physical form… Hope you’re well too :) Will miss your cuteness & voice on here ;)

Fission Mailed
January 8th, 2010 - 7:51pm

“CFGames will return in the new year with an exciting revamp that will keep you entertained and someone very exciting bringing it to you…”

Any news… it’s almost 3 months since this was posted.

Ron
January 16th, 2010 - 2:28am

Too bad Zoe’s gone (hope all is well with you)…she at least could have kept providing some interesting gaming insights while channelflip.com figured some things out…looking forward to the the new stuff ya’ll have planned nonetheless!

Fission Mailed
February 16th, 2010 - 6:56pm

Guess this part of the site is dead forever now then, despite what WilHarris may have said… last October.

Thanks for the good times… sorry to see it go. :o(

Richard
February 23rd, 2010 - 1:25pm

RIP :(

add a comment

Subscribe to newsletter?